Why I don’t like evergreen funnels

Hi ,

A few years ago, I built the kind of funnel that online business dreams are made of.

A polished webinar.
A clean email sequence.
A high-converting offer.
It was evergreen. Automated. “Passive.”

And it worked… until it didn’t.

The sales slowed down.
Refunds crept up.
People stopped finishing the training.
And the leads that once felt excited? Now they felt cold.

I started second-guessing everything.

Was the messaging off?
Was the offer outdated?
Had I missed the window where this worked?

But the more I looked into it, the more obvious it became:

The problem wasn’t the funnel.
The problem was how still it had become.

Here’s the part nobody tells you:

Evergreen is fragile when it’s static.
It’s powerful when it’s dynamic.

Let me break this down with a framework I teach my clients called The Evergreen Engine Check - the 5 areas where most automated funnels quietly break down:

1. Relevance Decay

What used to feel urgent no longer hits.
Your audience's fears and desires evolve faster than most funnels do.

✅ Audit your hook and headline every 90 days.
Ask: “Would this still stop me in my scroll today?”

2. Conversion Event Fatigue

The masterclass that once converted at 12% has now dipped below 3%.
Not because it’s bad, but because your offer's sophistication has grown, and the content hasn’t kept up.

✅ Refresh or re-record your core conversion event seasonally.
Even small tweaks (like re-recording your intro and CTA) make a huge difference.

3. Objection Blindness

Over time, you stop hearing the no’s because the funnel is running silently.
But silence doesn’t mean satisfaction. It often means confusion.

✅ Review every “no” and “not yet” response from the last 3 months.
What patterns are hiding in plain sight?

4. Outdated Proof

Testimonials from two years ago don’t create trust in a fast-moving market.
You need social proof that reflects the now.

✅ Rotate in fresh stories and screenshots from the last 90 days.
Especially from people who match your current ideal client.

5. Static Nurture

Your leads don’t stop learning just because they’re on your list.
If your funnel nurture doesn’t evolve, your cold leads will go somewhere warmer.

✅ Build a reactivation loop.
Every 30 days, send a story-driven value email that restarts the conversation.

Evergreen works, but not by default.
It works when you treat it like a living, breathing part of your business.

And the most successful founders I know?
They don’t “set it and forget it.”
They watch, listen, tweak, and test.

Not constantly. Not obsessively.
But rhythmically, intentionally, and with data in hand.

Because a great funnel isn’t just built once.
It’s tended to.

Like a garden.
Like a brand.
Like a business designed to last.

Passive income is a myth, but being able to generate revenue while you sleep isn’t. It’ll work if you work it.

XO,

Natalie

🤳This week was content recording week for me, and if you’ve ever tried batch-creating without a plan, you know how overwhelming it can feel. That’s why I follow a system. It’s exactly how I shoot months of high-converting B-roll in just a few hours. I’m breaking it all down for you in this playbook.

✨Every Sunday, we send an exclusive email designed for CEO Mamas who are balancing business growth + motherhood. We offer tangible strategies, practical tools, and nervous system resets to help you streamline your business, simplify your schedule, and find more connection in the day-to-day. If you’re ready for weekly, actionable support that makes you feel seen - this is for you. Click here, like the post and we’ll know to add you to the list!

If your evergreen funnel hasn’t been touched in over 90 days - pause. Run this audit first:

1. Rewatch your conversion event.

   • Does it still reflect your best thinking?

   • Would your current audience binge this start to finish?
     Highlight 1–2 spots where the messaging feels dated or energy feels low.
     

2. List every objection you've heard lately.

   • Go through emails, DMs, sales calls, unsubscribes.

   • What new hesitations are showing up that your funnel doesn’t address?
     

3. Pull your last 10 testimonials.

   • Are they recent? Specific? From your current ICA?

   • If not, flag this as your #1 trust gap to fix.
     

4. Map the customer drop-off points.

   • Where are people opting out? Not clicking? Not buying?

   • Prioritize 1 action per drop-off zone: update subject lines, cut fluff, clarify your CTA.
     

5. Set a rhythm.

   • Schedule a 30-min Evergreen CEO Check-in every quarter.

   • Assign 1 data point to track + 1 tweak to test.

You don’t need to rebuild the funnel.
You just need to maintain the engine.

🚀 The Société: Your go-to membership for building a Freedom-Based Business™ with 60+ templates, weekly coaching, and a powerful community of women entrepreneurs. Join the membership here.

👩‍👧 CEO Mama Membership: A membership designed for entrepreneurial moms balancing business and motherhood with expert guidance and a supportive community. Apply to be a member.